top of page
  • Writer's pictureJ B

Stay with QuickBooks or Upgrade to ERP? A Cost-Benefit Analysis

Performing a cost-benefit analysis is a valuable approach to compare the use of QuickBooks and spreadsheets with upgrading to a modern cloud ERP system like NetSuite. Here's the analysis:

Cost Analysis:

  • QuickBooks: Consider the subscription fees for QuickBooks plans, the need for add-ons or integrations, and any training or support costs involved. Additionally, assess the time and effort required for manual data entry and reconciliation in QuickBooks, which can impact labor costs.

  • Spreadsheets: Evaluate the time spent on manual data entry, formula creation, and reconciliation in spreadsheets. Consider the labor costs associated with maintaining and updating spreadsheets, as well as the potential for errors that could lead to financial discrepancies.

  • Cloud ERP Upgrade: Assess the costs associated with the cloud ERP upgrade, including licensing fees, implementation costs, data migration, training, and ongoing subscription fees. Consider potential savings in labor costs due to automation, improved accuracy, and streamlined processes.

Need a price quote on NetSuite Cloud ERP for your business? Just ask.

Efficiency and Productivity:

  • QuickBooks: Evaluate the efficiency of QuickBooks in terms of automated processes, real-time financial insights, and ease of use. Consider the productivity gains from automated data entry, streamlined reporting, and integrated features like invoicing and payment processing.

  • Spreadsheets: Assess the limitations of spreadsheets, such as manual data entry, version control issues, and time-consuming formula creation. Consider the potential for errors, lack of real-time data, and the need for manual data consolidation.

  • Cloud ERP Upgrade: Consider the efficiency gains from a modern cloud ERP system, including automation of routine tasks, real-time data availability, streamlined workflows, and integrated functionalities across departments. Evaluate the impact on productivity due to improved collaboration, reporting capabilities, and data accuracy.

Scalability and Adaptability:

  • QuickBooks: Consider the scalability of QuickBooks in relation to the company's growth plans. Assess whether it can handle increasing data volumes, the addition of new users, and the expansion into new markets or locations.

  • Spreadsheets: Evaluate the limitations of spreadsheets regarding scalability and adaptability. Consider how spreadsheets may become cumbersome and error-prone as the business grows, making it difficult to manage increasing complexities.

  • Cloud ERP Upgrade: Assess the scalability and adaptability of a modern cloud ERP system, considering its ability to handle growing business needs, support multi-location operations, and accommodate increased user access. Evaluate its potential for customization and integration with other systems.

Data Accuracy and Compliance:

  • QuickBooks: Evaluate the accuracy of financial data in QuickBooks and its ability to generate compliant financial reports. Consider any challenges related to data integrity, reconciliation, and audit trail.

  • Spreadsheets: Assess the risks of data errors, inconsistencies, and formula mistakes in spreadsheets. Consider the challenges of ensuring data accuracy, compliance with accounting standards, and managing data security.

  • Cloud ERP Upgrade: Consider the improved data accuracy and integrity offered by a modern cloud ERP system through automated processes, centralized data management, and built-in controls. Evaluate its compliance features and ability to generate accurate and reliable financial reports.

Long-Term Business Impact:

  • QuickBooks: Consider how QuickBooks may meet the immediate needs of the business but may lack the scalability and advanced functionalities required for long-term growth and strategic initiatives.

  • Spreadsheets: Assess the limitations of spreadsheets in supporting the evolving needs of the business, including increased complexity, integration requirements, and the potential for errors or data loss.

  • Cloud ERP Upgrade: Evaluate the long-term benefits of a cloud ERP upgrade, including the ability to scale with the business, support strategic initiatives, improve decision-making with real-time insights, and provide a foundation for digital transformation.

By conducting a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis, considering factors such as cost, efficiency, scalability, data accuracy, and long-term impact, you can make an informed decision on whether upgrading to a modern cloud ERP system is the right choice for your business compared to using QuickBooks or spreadsheets. It's advisable to involve key stakeholders, such as finance, IT, and management, in the analysis process to ensure a thorough evaluation.

We can also help.

Our partner, Meyer, has been implementing ERP systems in organizations for nearly three decades. There's no one better to ask which modern ERP system (if any) is right for you than the people who've been doing it longer than just about anyone.

Or call/DM (516) 650-5805


John Barlowe


Need more info? Learn about Cloud ERP systems

8 views0 comments
bottom of page